Raymond Carr
Raymond Carr was a 20-year-old private serving in Camp Beauregard’s Military Police Detachment during World War II. Originally from Patterson, Louisiana, he was the son of Titus and Lorenza Carr and had ten siblings.
Incident
On the evening of Oct. 31, 1942, Pvt. Raymond Carr, a Black military policeman (MP) stationed at Camp Beauregard, was on duty in downtown Alexandria with his partner, Pvt. John Spears. Carr and Spears were patrolling a Black neighborhood of Alexandria that, in January, had been the site of the “Lee Street Riot.”
Spears stated that around 11 p.m., he and Carr encountered a Black man and woman arguing. They did not want to intervene and began walking away. Around the same time, a state police car pulled up. Two white troopers, Charles Grayson and R.H. White, got out of the car, armed with guns. Spears and Carr carried only nightsticks.
As the troopers approached, one of them asked what was going on. The woman said the man hit her. According to Spears, Carr stated, “That man didn’t hit that woman,” and a trooper responded, “You are trying to take authority over civilians.” The troopers told Carr and Spears they were under arrest and ordered them into the police car. Carr said, “We are on duty and can’t leave until properly relieved.” The two troopers went back to their car and drove away.
About ten minutes later, the police car returned and four white troopers exited. W.R. Anding aimed a shotgun at Spears and allegedly said, “Don’t run n–. I’ll blow your head off.” Spears surrendered; Carr turned and ran. Two of the troopers, White and Dalton McCollum, chased Carr on foot. McCollum said he ordered Carr to stop and fired two warning shots.
Another Black MP on duty that evening, Pfc. Roy Jones, was patrolling Lee Street when Carr ran by. Jones said he saw two troopers chasing Carr, guns drawn, and pulled Carr behind him as Carr repeatedly pleaded, “Don’t let them shoot me.” When the troopers approached, Jones said he suggested they all go one block over to speak with Carr’s superior. The troopers did not respond.
McCollum said that when Carr stopped, he began “cursing” the troopers. McCollum told Carr he was under arrest, Carr allegedly struck him with his nightstick, and then, according to McCollum, he drew his gun and shot Carr.
Jones, along with eight other witnesses, said that Carr never had a nightstick in his hand. Several witnesses said they saw one of the troopers hit or strike Carr at the same time McCollum fired. The only witnesses who said McCollum fired two warning shots were the four troopers.
Two witnesses heard Carr say, “I’m shot,” as he slumped forward. Lt. Allen Ellis, a white officer and Carr’s superior, ran toward the scene when he heard the gunshot. Ellis helped Carr into a civilian’s vehicle and rode with him to Baptist Hospital. Leaving Carr on a stretcher in the hallway, he returned to Lee Street.
1st Lt. Sidney Joffe, Medical Corps ward surgeon, reported to Baptist Hospital to get Carr. In the ambulance en route to Camp Livingston’s Station Hospital, Joffe questioned Carr about the shooting. Carr told Joffe that a trooper “got very abusive and profane” with him regarding his response to a man and woman fighting on the street. When the officers returned to the scene with two additional troopers, Carr said, one hit him above the right ear and another shot him in the abdomen.
I.A. McCrown, another Medical Corps ward surgeon, and Maj. George Benton Jr., assistant chief of surgical service, said that Carr arrived at Station Hospital around 3 a.m. McCrown examined Carr and noted a small cut on his head, described as an injury that would “ordinarily be the result of a blow struck by some instrument such as a club, blackjack, or gun barrel,” as well as a gunshot wound to the abdomen. Benton and McCrown operated on Carr at 4:49 a.m. Benton said Carr was “wide awake, alert” the following day. At 9 p.m., Carr issued another statement in the presence of medical personnel.
When Benton examined Carr around 8:30 a.m. on Nov. 3, he discovered a hemothorax. Carr’s condition worsened. At 10:30 a.m., he asked a nurse for his father, stating, “I want him to know it was not my fault.”
At 11:30 p.m., Carr asked another nurse for a doctor. Struggling to breathe, Carr swore that the statements he made to doctors about the shooting were true. He died at 2:50 a.m.
Aftermath
On Nov. 4, Camp Beauregard’s Board of Officers heard from several witnesses and Maj. Gen. Richard Donovan initiated a War Department investigation of Carr’s killing, headed by Lt. Col. Julien Hyer.
Carr was buried at Willing Workers Cemetery in Patterson.
On Nov. 6, the state police denied the Army’s formal request to arrest McCollum. At their headquarters, Assistant Superintendent L.A. Newsome told Col. K.F. Hanst that he “would not place any state trooper in arrest for shooting a n–.”
Hyer completed his report on Nov. 13, writing, “An American soldier on his official post of duty was shot down in… cold blood,” and concluding, “Something must be done to bring his murderer to justice.”
Donovan notified the adjutant general, Maj. James Alexander Ulio, of Hyer’s report and suggested the Department of Justice (DOJ) assess whether the shooting violated any federal statutes.
On Dec. 8 Ulio reported that the DOJ sent G. Maynard Smith to Louisiana to investigate Carr’s killing. Thomas Phillips, Army special investigator, continued the War Department investigation. He completed two additional reports, one on Dec. 5 and the other on Dec. 18.
Smith updated Victor Rotnem, chief of the DOJ’s civil rights section, on Dec. 15. He reported that while the Army had done a “splendid job” investigating, “no help can be expected from the state authorities in the prosecution of this case.” Three days later, U.S. Attorney for the Western District of Louisiana Malcolm Lafargue sent a telegram to Assistant Attorney General Wendell Berge expressing the opinion that federal jurisdiction in the Carr case was “doubtful.”
Smith met with Louisiana Gov. Samuel Jones on Jan. 1, 1943. Jones agreed “to give the prosecution his wholehearted support,” ensuring the case would be prosecuted “by his attorney general,” rather than a local state attorney. On March 6, Berge wrote that the district attorney assigned to prosecute Carr’s case, Benjamin Thompson, was “not enthusiastic” and had “made very little preparation for a vigorous prosecution.”
According to a March 22 memorandum from Berge to Attorney General Francis Biddle, a Rapides Parish grand jury convened on March 10 and “spent two full days hearing all the facts.” Smith, Berge wrote, “was allowed to plan the presentation, and direct the investigation, as far as possible, without being in the grand jury room.” On March 13, a jury declined to indict McCollum. Biddle wrote on March 20, “in view of the full and fair investigation… and the return of a No Bill, it is my recommendation that no further action be taken, and that the file be closed.” The DOJ did not pursue federal prosecution.
McCollum died in 1951. Spears, who served in the Army until August 1944, died in 1977.
Case summaries are compiled using government records and archival primary source material. These include, but are not limited to, investigative records, arrest reports, newspaper articles, court filings, census records, birth and death certificates, transcripts, and press releases. In many cases, the records contain contradictory assertions.
Media Gallery
In addition to the incident files associated with this case, this summary relied on the following:
Archival Sources
- Applications for Headstones, January 1, 1925-June 30, 1970; Records of the Office of the Quartermaster General, 1774-1985; Record Group 92; National Archives, St. Louis, Missouri
- Department of Corrections, San Quentin State Prison Records, 1850–1950; California State Archives, Office of the Secretary of State, Sacramento, California
- Hospital Admission Card Files, Records of the Office of the Surgeon General (Army), 1775-1994; Record Group 12; National Archives, College Park, Maryland
- NAACP Records: Legal File; Soldier Killing, Carr, Raymond, 1942-43
- Records of the Secretary of War: Records of the Office of the Assistant Secretary of War; Civilian Aide to the Secretary-Subject File; General Correspondence (Judge Hastie), 1940-1948; Violence Against Negro Military Personnel; National Archives, College Park, Maryland
- World War II Army Enlistment Records;World War II Army Enlistment Records; Records of the National Archives and Records Administration, Record Group 64; National Archives at College Park; College Park, Maryland
Genealogical Records
- Certificate of Birth, State of Louisiana Bureau of Vital Statistics, 1917, 1920, 1923
- Louisiana Statewide Death Index, Louisiana, United States, 1919, 1942
- Population Schedule for St. Mary Parish, Louisiana, United States Federal Census, 1920, 1930, 1940, 1950
- Social Security Administration, Social Security Death Index, Master File, Louisiana, United States, 1925
- Vital Records Indices; State of Louisiana, Division of Archives; Baton Rouge, Louisiana, 1941
- World War II Draft Registration Card, Illinois, United States, 1942
- World War II Draft Registration Card, Louisiana, United States, 1940, 1942
News Coverage
- “Army Can Protect Soldiers From Civilian Violence–Why Doesn’t It?” Baltimore Afro-American, November 27, 1943
- “Army Orders Probe of MP’s Slaying: State Trooper Held at Fault in Official Report,” New Journal and Guide (Norfolk, VA), November 28, 1942
- “Bill Makes Attack on Uniform Federal Crime,” New Journal and Guide (Norfolk, VA), July 3, 1943
- “Demand Action Against Trooper Who Killed MP: War Officials Urge Full Punishment,” Atlanta Daily World, November 18, 1942
- “FD Asked to Halt Killing of Soldiers: Judge Hastie’s Report to Lawyers’ Guild Accuses Police,” Baltimore Afro-American, July 24, 1943
- “Grand Jury Refuses to Indict Cop Who Killed Negro Soldier,” New York Age (New York, NY), April 24, 1943
- “Grand Jury Refuses to Indict Killer of Soldier in Louisiana,” Call and Post (Cleveland, OH), May 1, 1943
- “Hit Refusal to Try Killer of Soldier: U.S. Atty. General Won’t Prosecute State Trooper Who Shot Carr,” The Chicago Defender, May 8, 1943
- “Hits U.S. Failure to Prosecute State Trooper for Slaying Soldier,” The New York Age (New York, NY), May 8, 1943
- “Jury Won’t Indict Cop in Slaying,” The Chicago Defender, April 24, 1943
- “Justice Department to Probe Killing of MP in Louisiana,” Call and Post (Cleveland, OH), November 28, 1942
- “La. Cop Who Killed M.P. Still at Large,” Baltimore Afro-American, November 21, 1942
- “La. Grand Jury Refuses to Indict Killer of Soldier,” The Louisiana Weekly (New Orleans, LA), April 24, 1943
- “Lodges Protest on Slaying of Soldier: NAACP Wires Secretary of War to Take Action Against Louisiana State Trooper Who Killed MP on Duty,” The Pittsburgh Courier, November 28, 1942
- “MP, 21, Slain by White Cop in Louisiana: Hastie Denies That Ten Died in Louisiana Army Riot Last Year,” Baltimore Afro-American, November 21, 1942
- “NAACP Flays M.P.’s Slaying: Demands Stimson Act to End Crimes in South,” New York Amsterdam Star-News (New York, NY), December 5, 1942
- “NAACP Hits U.S. Failure in La. Murder: Soldier-Killer Goes Free From Federal Move,” Atlanta Daily World, May 5, 1943
- “Negro Military Policeman Shot by State Police,” The Town Talk (Alexandria, LA), November 2, 1942
- “Police Shoots Negro MP After Being Attacked,” Advocate (Baton Rouge, LA), November 3, 1942
- “Rapides Jury Returns 4 True, Nine No Bills: 18 Cases Called to Attention of Parish Panel,” The Town Talk (Alexandria, LA), March 15, 1943
- “State Police Force Sergeant McCollum, of this City, Dies,” The Planters Press (Bossier City, LA), January 4, 1951
- “Urge War Dept. to Punish Killer Cop,” Baltimore Afro-American, April 24, 1943
- Ralph Brown, “Race MP Slain; La. Defies U.S. Action,” The Pittsburgh Courier, November 21, 1942
- Ben Davis Jr., “Time for Action by War Dep’t,” Daily Worker (New York, NY), February 7, 1943
- Adam Lapin, “It Was Murder! Why No Action on Shooting of Negro Soldiers?” Daily Worker (New York, NY), May 16, 1943
- George S. Schuyler, “Views and Reviews,” The Pittsburgh Courier, May 8, 1943