Robert "Bobbie" Hall
Robert “Bobbie” Hall was a 31-year-old mechanic who lived in Newton, Georgia with his wife, Annie Pearl, and their eight-year-old son, Willie.
Incident
Robert “Bobbie” Hall, spent Jan. 29, 1943 working at his garage in Newton, Georgia. According to several witnesses, Hall, who was Black, left work around 7 p.m. to fix a car for white service station operator Joe White. Hall’s wife, Annie Pearl, said he arrived home at 9 p.m.
White and Cal Hall Jr. told the FBI that Baker County Sheriff Mack Claude Screws arrived at White’s garage around 9:30 p.m. According to White, Screws, “obviously drunk,” stated he was “going to get Bob Hall,” and asked Cal Hall to join. He declined. About 30 minutes later, Cal Hall saw Screws with Jim Bob Kelley and Newton Night Patrolman Frank Jones at Johnny West’s Barroom.
Several barroom witnesses told the FBI they saw Screws, Jones, and Kelley, all white, drinking. West told the FBI Jones and Kelley stated, “We’re wasting time, that negro will get away.”
Screws, however, told the FBI that he was at his office working the night of Jan. 29. He said that around midnight, shortly after Newton farmer George Durham delivered a warrant from Justice of the Peace T.A. Riley for alleged tire theft by Robert Hall, Screws ordered Jones and Kelley to arrest Hall.
In several statements, Annie Pearl Hall said that she answered the door around midnight. Jones said he had a warrant to arrest Robert Hall. After confiscating a shotgun, according to Hall, Jones brought her husband out to the car without “argument or any kind of trouble.”
Screws told the FBI that he was drinking from the courthouse well when the car arrived around 12:30 a.m. Screws later told the FBI that when he ordered Hall out, he noticed Hall holding a shotgun, knocked it away from him, and caused it to fire as Hall fell to the ground. Screws said he punched Hall “about the face and head” and Jones “hit him a lick or two” with his blackjack, stating Hall was not handcuffed and they stopped when he collapsed. He ordered Kelley and Jones to “carry” Hall to jail.
White witnesses who lived nearby told the FBI and, later, a jury a different version of events. Bess Ledbetter told the FBI that she awoke to sounds of “loud cursing and talking” around 1 a.m., including a man yelling, “Hit him again, hit him again.” Her husband, Adolphus, told the FBI he observed three men taking turns beating someone on the ground and phoned Newton police officer Byron Edwards, but was advised Edwards had already left for the scene. Ledbetter said Edwards never showed.
The Ledbetters said that 30 minutes later, one man got in the car and drove away while the others dragged the person on the ground to the courthouse.
White witnesses in the jail saw Jones and Kelley drag a handcuffed and bloody Hall inside.
Screws told agents that Jones and Kelley came to his office to report Hall was “in pretty bad shape,” so he called white Albany physician James Barnett to notify him of an incoming patient.
Henry Neal, a Black undertaker at Walter Poteat’s Funeral Home in Albany, told the FBI he received a call from a hospital nurse between 1:30 and 2 a.m. on Jan. 30. The nurse relayed that Screws had called for an ambulance “to come get a negro that he had to beat up.” Neal informed Walter Poteat and left for Newton with Poteat’s son, Manley.
Both Neal and Manley Poteat told the FBI that upon arrival, they saw Hall crawling on all fours in a pool of blood. They transported him to Albany. Neal told the FBI that Hall “died before he was taken off the cot” in the emergency room.
Aftermath
Barnett completed Hall’s death certificate, recording that Hall died at 3:30 a.m. from a fractured skull. Barnett told agents he saw “drag burns” on Hall’s chest, shoulders, and chin, but no evidence of handcuffs.
According to Walter Poteat and Neal, Hall had large holes in his head and was covered in dirt, sand, and blood. They also described “rings around each wrist where the skin was gone.” A.C. Searles, founding editor of The Southwest Georgian, took photographs of Hall’s body, sending them to the NAACP.
In the morning, Annie Pearl Hall and her father-in-law, Will, went into town to retrieve Robert. Will Hall told the FBI that he noticed “lots of blood around the well” by the courthouse and recognized one of Robert's shoes. The “trail of blood” they followed to the jail looked, Annie Pearl Hall stated, “like someone had dragged a sack of meal through the ground.”
Annie Pearl and Will Hall traveled to the hospital, where they learned Robert had died.
Robert Hall’s funeral took place in Newton on Feb. 3. According to NAACP correspondence, Annie Pearl Hall relocated to Florida immediately after.
The NAACP forwarded affidavits to the Department of Justice (DOJ), requesting investigation. It also sent copies of Searles’ photographs to major newspapers for publication and wrote to Gov. Ellis Arnall urging Screws’ ousting.
According to a March 6, 1943 FBI report, several white Albany police officers reported Hall’s killing to the FBI on Feb. 8. The DOJ formally requested an FBI investigation on Feb. 12. Agents from the FBI’s Atlanta field office began interviews on Feb. 19.
A federal grand jury in Macon indicted Screws, Jones, and Kelley on three counts of federal civil rights violations in April 1943.
Screws, Jones, and Kelley stood trial on Oct. 4, 1943 in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Georgia in Albany. Among the federal government’s 38 witnesses was FBI handwriting expert Hubert Davis, who concluded that Screws, not Durham or Riley, had written the warrant for Hall’s arrest.
On Oct. 7, 1943, an all-white jury returned guilty verdicts on two counts. Screws, Kelley, and Jones were each sentenced to consecutive one- and two-year prison sentences and $1,000 fines.
Following appeal, in a Jan. 14, 1944 decision, the judges for the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit in New Orleans, Louisiana upheld the convictions.
Annie Pearl Hall filed suit in city court on May 8, 1944. The jury found in favor of the defendants.
On May 7, 1945, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a decision in Screws et al. v. U.S., ordering a retrial. Justice William O. Douglas’ majority opinion affirmed the federal government’s authority to intervene in incidents of civil rights violations performed under “the color of law,” but ruled that juries must be properly instructed as to the definition of “willfully” depriving a victim of their civil rights.
Following an unsuccessful motion for retrial in Annie Pearl Hall’s civil suit, the Georgia Court of Appeals reconsidered the case on June 30, 1945. It affirmed the decision of the city court.
On Oct. 29, 1945, the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Georgia in Albany retried the defendants. The jury returned three not guilty verdicts on Nov. 1.
Screws, reelected as sheriff prior to his 1945 acquittal, died in 1965. Jones died in 1968, Kelley in 1980.
Willie Hall died in 1996. Annie Pearl Hall (then Annie Hunter) died in 2000.
Case summaries are compiled using government records and archival primary source material. These include, but are not limited to, investigative records, arrest reports, newspaper articles, court filings, census records, birth and death certificates, transcripts, and press releases. In many cases, the records contain contradictory assertions.
Media Gallery
In addition to the incident files associated with this case, this summary relied on the following:
Archival Sources
- Case Records: Court of Appeals, Clerk of Court; Case File for 30712, Hall v. National Surety Corporation et al.; Georgia Archives, Morrow, Georgia
- Docket Books: Entry for Case 30712, Hall v. National Surety Corporation et al.; Georgia Archives, Morrow, Georgia
- The Felix Frankfurter Papers: United States Supreme Court Case Files of Opinions and Memoranda October Terms 1938-1952; October Term 1944; Drafts of Miscellaneous Opinions and Memoranda; American Legal Manuscripts from the Harvard Law School Library; Cambridge, Massachusetts
- The Felix Frankfurter Papers: United States Supreme Court Case Files of Opinions and Memoranda October Terms 1938-1952; October Term 1944; Screws v. U.S.; American Legal Manuscripts from the Harvard Law School Library; Cambridge, Massachusetts
- NAACP Records: General Office File, 1940-1956; Lynching; Hall, Robert, 1943; Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.
- NAACP Records: Legal File; Crime; Screws, M. Claude, 1944-1945; Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.
- NAACP Records: Legal File; General; Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.
Genealogical Records
- Certificate of Death, Bureau of Vital Statistics, Georgia State Board of Health, United States, 1910, 1937, 1943
- Florida Marriage Index, 1927-2001, Florida Department of Health, United States, 1954
- Georgia Death Records, Georgia Department of Health and Vital Statistics, United States, 1945, 1964, 1965, 1968, 1980
- Population Schedule for Baker County, Georgia, United States Federal Census, 1920, 1940, 1950
- Population Schedule for Dougherty County, Georgia, United States Federal Census, 1940
- Population Schedule for Miller County, Georgia, United States Federal Census, 1930
- Population Schedule for Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida, United States Federal Census, 1950
- Social Security Administration, Social Security Applications and Claims, 1936-2007, Georgia, United States, 1996
- Social Security Administration, Social Security Death Index, Master File, Georgia, United States, 1964, 1965
- World War II Draft Registration Cards, Georgia, 1940, 1942
News Coverage
- “$7,500 Bail Frees Georgia Lynch Cop,” New York Amsterdam News, November 6, 1943
- “Admitted Slayer is Shot to Death: J. Williams Killed by Officers; Hunt Body Willie Mathis,” Savannah Evening Press (Savannah, GA), May 11, 1937
- “An Inescapable Verdict,” Atlanta Daily World (Atlanta, GA), October 10, 1943
- “An Inevitable Indictment,” Atlanta Daily World (Atlanta, GA), April 14, 1943
- “Another Blot on the South,” Atlanta Daily World (Atlanta, GA), February 10, 1943
- “Arnell Asked to Remove, Arrest Sheriff in Lynch Murder of Georgia Negro,” Call and Post (Cleveland, OH), February 27, 1943
- “Asks Indictment in Hall Lynching,” New York Amsterdam Star-News, February 20, 1943
- “Court Calendar,” The Atlanta Constitution (Atlanta, GA), December 20, 1944
- “Court Calendar,” The Atlanta Journal (Atlanta, GA), December 20, 1944
- “Court Studies Baker Case,” The Atlanta Constitution (Atlanta, GA), December 16, 1943
- “Civil Rights Law Invoked by U.S. Jury,” The Macon News (Macon, GA), April 11, 1943
- “Clevelander Describes Horror of Georgia’s Latest Lynching,” Call and Post (Cleveland, OH), February 13, 1943
- “Dixie Sheriff Indicted: FBI Acts in Death of Mob Victim,” The Pittsburgh Courier, April 17, 1943
- “Ga. Lynch Victim’s Widow Files Suit for $14,750,” Baltimore Afro-American, February 5, 1944
- “Ga. Officers Indicted in Prisoner’s Death,” Baltimore Afro-American, April 17, 1943
- “Ga. Youth Kidnapped, Brutally Beaten By Sheriff in First Lynching of 1943,” The Chicago Defender, February 13, 1943
- “Georgia Provides First Lynching of 1943: Mechanic Beaten to Death in Baker County,” Atlanta Daily World, February 5, 1943
- “Georgia Sheriff, Named in Lynch Bill, Is Wounded,” Atlanta Daily World (Atlanta, GA), July 9, 1943
- “High Court Votes 5-4: New Trial for Georgia Sheriff, 2 Policemen,” The Pittsburgh Courier, May 19, 1945
- “In Comes Sheriff Screws,” Atlanta Daily World (Atlanta, GA), October 22, 1944
- “Indict Baker County Sheriff on Charge of Beating Mechanic to Death,” The Savannah Tribune (Savannah, GA), April 15, 1943
- “Indict Sheriff in Ga. Lynching,” Atlanta Daily World (Atlanta, GA), April 11, 1943
- “Induct Editor Who Exposed Ga. Lynching: Board Refuses Deferment of Searles Who Had Sheriff Indicted,” The Chicago Defender, July 3, 1943
- “Jim Bob Kelley[sic] Posts Bond,” The Baker County News (Newton, GA), February 4, 1944
- “Judge Bascom Deaver,” Atlanta Daily World (Atlanta, GA), October 15, 1944
- “Jury Convicts So. Georgia Officers in Hall Lynching: Three Face Penal Terms, Fines for January 29 Crime,” Atlanta Daily World (Atlanta, GA), October 8, 1943
- “Kidnaped and Lynched in Georgia: Brutal Death Attributed to Sheriff’s Ire,” New York Amsterdam Star-News, February 13, 1943
- “Lynch Sheriff Renominated,” The Pittsburgh Courier, March 18, 1944
- “Lynch Widow Asks Damages: Robert Hall’s Widow Sues for $3,000 and Fees,” Atlanta Daily World (Atlanta, GA), January 26, 1944
- “Lynching Details Exposed,” The Pittsburgh Courier, February 20, 1943
- “Man in Custody Said Whipped,” The Atlanta Constitution (Atlanta, GA), October 7, 1943
- “Most Meritorious Service by Peace Officer,” The Atlanta Constitution (Atlanta, GA), May 15, 1938
- “Negro’s Attack on Him Related by Sheriff Screws,” The Baker County News (Newton, GA), February 12, 1943
- Obituary for Annie P. Hunter, Tallahassee Democrat (Tallahassee, FL), October 5, 2000
- Obituary for Willie Hall, Tallahassee Democrat (Tallahassee, FL), March 17, 1996
- “Officers Acquitted in Hall’s Slaying,” New Journal and Guide (Norfolk, VA), November 24, 1945
- “Open Retrial of Dixie Sheriff: Beat, Killed Negro, Witnesses Testify,” The Chicago Defender, November 10, 1945
- “Poetic Justice Comes to Negro Killer in Georgia,” The Chicago Defender, August 7, 1943
- “Retaliation Against the Pen,” Atlanta Daily World (Atlanta, GA), June 23, 1943
- “Sad Funeral for Lynching Victim,” Atlanta Daily World (Atlanta, GA), February 5, 1943
- “Sheriff, Cop Suspected in Ga. Lynching,” Baltimore Afro-American, February 13, 1943
- “Sheriff Denies Negro Lynched: Newspaper Accusation Draws Counter Claim,” The Columbus Ledger (Columbus, GA), February 11, 1943
- “Sheriff Given 3-Year Term in Ga. Lynching: U.S. Attorneys Win in Second Trial of Case,” The Chicago Defender, October 16, 1943
- “Sheriff Screws May Lose Sight of Both Eyes: Officer Under Indictment in Lynching Case,” Atlanta Daily World (Atlanta, GA), July 10, 1943
- “Sheriff Screws’ Trial Reopens at Albany, Ga.,” Atlanta Daily World (Atlanta, GA), October 31, 1945
- “U.S. Court Affirms Police Conviction,” New Journal and Guide (Norfolk, VA), January 22, 1944
- “U.S. to Fight Appeal in Civil Rights Case,” The Washington Post, November 3, 1943
- “Willie Mathis is Found Alive: Was Believed Slain by Negro Who Was Shot to Death,” Savannah Evening Press (Savannah, GA), May 13, 1937
- “Witnesses Tell of Hall’s Being Fatally Flogged: Whites Describes Scene Where Baker Lynching Occurred,” Atlanta Daily World (Atlanta, GA), October 7, 1943
- L. P. Bucksell, “Conviction of Georgia Sheriff, Police Upheld,” The Pittsburgh Courier, January 22, 1944
- Cliff MacKay, “3 Georgia Cops Convicted in Jan. Lynching,” Baltimore Afro-American, October 16, 1943
- Marjorie McKenzie, “Fewer Lynchings? Yes, But Mob Spirit Reigns!” The Pittsburgh Courier, April 10, 1943
- M. S. Page, “Sidelights on the Claude Screws Trail,” Atlanta Daily World (Atlanta, GA), October 10, 1943
- Harold Preece, “The Living South,” The Chicago Defender, October 30, 1943
- Lewis Wood, “Police Win Retrial in Georgia Killing: Supreme Court Rules on Case of 3 Officers Accused of Beating Negro to Death,” The New York Times, May 8, 1945