Skip to main content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Dot gov

The .gov means it’s official.
Federal government websites often end in .gov or .mil. Before sharing sensitive information, make sure you’re on a federal government site.

Https

The site is secure.
The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the official website and that any information you provide is encrypted and transmitted securely.

Levi Dorsey

, Orange, Texas

Levi Dorsey was a 22-year-old Black man who lived in DeRidder, Louisiana, and worked as a farmhand and odd jobs to support his widowed mother.

View records at National Archives

Incident

On Jan. 31, 1951, Levi Dorsey traveled to nearby Orange, Texas to visit his brother, Leroy, and his sister-in-law. On Feb. 1, Levi Dorsey was arrested on a burglary charge after Orange Police Chief Alvin Keown said the police department had evidence linking him to a recent break-in at the Midway Cafe. Dorsey was detained at the jail in Orange, Texas. 

On Feb. 2, Keown signed complaints before the justice of the peace charging Levi and Leroy Dorsey and Joe Redmond with the burglary, later telling the FBI that Levi Dorsey had named Leroy Dorsey and Redmond as his accomplices. Orange police arrested Leroy Dorsey and Redmond. Redmond told FBI agents in an April 3 interview that he and Leroy Dorsey both told the police they had no knowledge about the burglary. 

Upon his arrival at the jail, Leroy Dorsey later testified in federal court, he noticed that Levi Dorsey’s face and body were swollen. According to Redmond’s FBI account, Assistant Chief Henry Stanfield hit Levi Dorsey and said he “ought to kill” him. Keown and Stanfield kicked and hit Levi Dorsey, insisting that he not lie about the burglary.

According to interviews with witnesses conducted by the FBI, Keown and Standfield hit Levi Dorsey while he was handcuffed. Keown told Officer Osval Folsom that he could shoot Levi Dorsey and Folsom pointed his gun at Levi Dorsey while Keown and Stanfield beat him. 

The white officers then moved Levi Dorsey to another cell and instructed Leroy Dorsey to, according to Dorsey, take a belt and “go in and beat Levi and make him tell the truth” or he would “be sorry.” Keown stood in the door of Levi Dorsey’s cell and told Leroy to stop talking and “beat the hell out of him.” When Leroy Dorsey stopped hitting his brother with the belt, Black Officer George Powell began beating Levi Dorsey with a rubber hose. An Aug. 1, 1951 FBI report summarized, “The beating of Levi Dorsey was observed and overheard by various witnesses from approximately 8:00 PM of the night of February 2, 1951 until approximately daybreak of the morning of February 3, 1951.”

Leroy Dorsey and Redmond were released at 11 p.m. on Feb. 2.

At one point in the night, officers took Levi Dorsey out to look for the money he allegedly stole from Midway Cafe. Officers from the Beauregard Police Department told the FBI that they heard that Orange police forced Dorsey to “dive into the water in a bayou at Orange” to recover money. Dorsey was returned to the jail “without dry clothes” in a cell that “did not contain heat or blankets.” The NAACP later confirmed via the weather bureau that it was 20 degrees that night.

Leroy Dorsey returned to visit his brother in jail on Feb. 4 and later told FBI agents that Levi Dorsey could not sit up without assistance. Levi Dorsey told his brother he hadn’t eaten anything since he was arrested. When Leroy Dorsey tried to feed his brother milk and juice through a straw, he later told FBI agents, “the juice would run out through his nose.” Leroy Dorsey returned to the jail on Feb. 8 to bring Levi Dorsey warmer clothes. Stanfield would not allow him to deliver the clothing and forbade him from bringing his brother any medicine or calling for a doctor.

On Feb. 9, Dorsey was released from jail. 

Helen Dorsey, Levi Dorsey’s sister, told FBI agents on April 3 that her brother returned home on Feb. 9. Dorsey told his sister and his mother that he had been “beaten up by the police” and that he didn’t believe he would live. Letha Dorsey, Levi Dorsey’s mother, told FBI agents that she bathed Dorsey and cleaned blood from his face, noted bruises on his back, and found burns on his legs and ankles. 

Helen Dorsey called a doctor who told her to bring Dorsey to the hospital, and she arranged for a friend to drive them to Beauregard Memorial Baptist Hospital the morning of Feb. 10. The FBI interviewed Dr. Paul Strecker and nurses who attended to Dorsey at the hospital, all of whom said that Dorsey’s face was “extremely swollen and his eyes partially closed,” and that he “hemorrhaged at the mouth and nose.” 

Dorsey died in the hospital on Feb. 12.

Aftermath

Dorsey was buried in Oakdale, Louisiana.

Leroy Dorsey testified in federal court that Stanfield approached him after his brother’s death and gave him $25 that he said was not a bribe and that he could get more “if he needed it.” He told Dorsey to bury his brother “without an inquest and as quick as he could.”

On April 5, 1951, newspapers reported that the Department of Justice (DOJ) had ordered a full FBI investigation into Dorsey’s death. Over the course of their investigation, the FBI found that Keown had assaulted and blinded a white man, William Grice, in September 1950, while detaining him at the Orange jail.

On April 25, an Orange County grand jury stated it was “unable to take any action” on Dorsey’s case.

In April, following the announcement of the FBI investigation, the Orange police officers collected signed statements from some of the men detained at the Orange jail while Dorsey was there. Several of the men later retracted these statements when they testified in the federal case, stating that they had been coerced into signing them. The same men, when interviewed by the FBI, gave statements consistent with their later court testimony. The officers also produced alleged signed confessions by Levi Dorsey, one of which concluded, “The officers have been good to me. None of the policemen have hurt me in any way.” On May 24, 1951, J. Edgar Hoover sent a telegram to the Houston FBI office, warning that “witnesses may have been intimidated.” 

On Sept. 11, 1951, a federal grand jury in Beaumont, Texas indicted Keown, Stanfield, Folsom, and Powell on two counts, for depriving Dorsey of his constitutional rights and conspiracy to deprive Dorsey of his constitutional rights while he was detained. 

The case went to federal court in November. All four officers took the stand and denied beating Dorsey. 

Jack Dismuke, a former identification officer for the police department, testified that on Feb. 3 he was asked to fingerprint Dorsey but was unable to do so because Dorsey’s hands were so swollen. He successfully fingerprinted Dorsey on Feb. 9. Dismuke testified that Keown asked him on April 7 and again on April 21 and 26 to make a statement that he had neither fingerprinted Dorsey nor seen officers beat him. On May 20, Keown visited Dismuke and offered to arrange for him to have several days paid time off in exchange for testifying in front of a federal grand jury that he had not seen Dorsey’s injuries or witnessed a beating. 

An all-white jury found all four officers innocent on both counts.

Keown died on Jan. 1, 2000. Stanfield died on Dec. 24, 1993. Folsom died on Oct. 20, 1991. Powell died on Oct. 17, 1996.

Leroy Dorsey died on July 9, 2001 in Beaumont, Texas.

Case summaries are compiled using government records and archival primary source material. These include, but are not limited to, investigative records, arrest reports, newspaper articles, court filings, census records, birth and death certificates, transcripts, and press releases. In many cases, the records contain contradictory assertions.

Media Gallery

In addition to the incident files associated with this case, this summary relied on the following:

Genealogical Records

  • Social Security Death Index, Texas, United States, 1935-2014

News Coverage

  • “4 Cops Indicted in Death Probe,” Chicago Daily News, September 12, 1951
  • “4 Officers Charged with Beating Negro,” Abilene Reporter-News (Abilene, TX), September 12, 1951
  • “4 Officers Freed in Beating Trial,” San Antonio Express, November 18, 1951
  • “4 Policemen Acquitted,” New York Times, November 19, 1951
  • “4 Policemen of Orange to Face U.S. Court Today,” Beaumont Enterprise (Beaumont, TX), September 12, 1951
  • “40 Witnesses at Cop Trial,” Waco Times-Herald (Waco, TX), November 15, 1951
  • “Civic Leader Stanfield Dies,” Orange Leader (Orange, TX), December 25, 1993
  • “Death of Man After Orange Arrest Probed,” Beaumont Journal (Beaumont, TX), March 29, 1951
  • “Decision Due Today in Orange Negro’s Civil Rights Case,” Abilene Reporter-News (Abilene, TX), November 16, 1951
  • “Doctor Says Orange Negro Not Abused,” Abilene Reporter-News (Abilene, TX), November 15, 1951
  • “Each Defendant Pleads Not Guilty to All Counts,” Beaumont Journal (Beaumont, TX), September 13, 1951
  • “Ex-Orange Officer Says Chief Told Him What to Say,” San Antonio Express, November 15, 1951
  • “Fancy Watches Given Lawyers Defending Cops,” Tyler Courier-Times (Tyler, TX), December 17, 1951
  • “FBI Probe of Jail Death Said ‘Tempest,’” San Angelo Standard-Times (San Angelo, TX), April 6, 1951
  • “FBI Probes Death of Negro in South,” Daily Compass (New York City, NY), April 5, 1951
  • “FBI to Probe Death of Man in Dequincy,” Morning Advocate (Baton Rouge, LA), April 5, 1951
  • “FBI to Probe Death of Negro,” Seattle Daily Times, April 4, 1951
  • “Final Arguments Mark Officer Trial,” Beaumont Journal (Beaumont, TX), November 17, 1951
  • “Four Police Indicted After Negro Beaten,” San Angelo Evening Standard (San Angelo, TX), September 12, 1951
  • “Grand Jury Backs State’s Efforts to Ban Slot Machines,” Orange Leader (Orange, TX), April 12, 1951
  • “Grand Jury Finds It Impossible to Make Full Probe of Alleged Jail Mistreatment,” Orange Leader (Orange, TX), April 26, 1951
  • “Jail Beating ‘Ordered,’ Court Told,” Houston Chronicle, November 13, 1951
  • “Judge Asks Windup Today in Trial of 4 Orange Officers,” Beaumont Journal (Beaumont, TX), November 16, 1961
  • “Jury Finds Orange Police Innocent,” Beaumont Enterprise (Beaumont, TX), November 18, 1951
  • “Jury Leaves Probe to FBI,” Beaumont Journal (Beaumont, TX), April 26, 1951
  • “Lawyers Get Watches for Police Defense,” San Angelo Evening Standard (San Angelo, TX), December 7, 1951
  • “More Witnesses Due in Beaumont Copy Trial,” Waco Times-Herald (Waco, TX), November 16, 1951
  • “Negro Says Orange Police Told Him to Beat Brother,”Corpus Christi Times (Corpus Christi, TX), November 13, 1951
  • “Orange Chief is Out–Assistant May Also Resign,” Port Arthur News (Port Arthur, TX), May 13, 1952
  • “Orange Cops Acquitted in Negro’s Case,” Abilene Reporter-News (Abilene, TX), November 18, 1951
  • “Orange Cops Stand Trial in Negro Case,” Abilene Reporter-News (Abilene, TX), November 13, 1951
  • “Orange Men at Hearing,” Beaumont Journal (Beaumont, TX), September 5, 1951
  • “Orange Officer Trial About to Go to Jurors,” Beaumont Journal (Beaumont, TX), November 17, 1951
  • “Orange Officers Found Not Guilty,” Orange Leader (Orange, TX), November 18, 1951
  • “Orange Officers’ Trial Set for U.S. Court Today,” Beaumont Enterprise (Beaumont, TX), November 12, 1951
  • “Orange Officers’ Trials to Open in City Monday,” Beaumont Enterprise (Beaumont, TX), November 10, 1951
  • “Orange Police Chief, Three Others Indicted,” Orange Leader (Orange, TX), September 11, 1951
  • “Orange Police Freed by Jury in Rights Case,” Dallas Morning News, November 18, 1951
  • “Orange Police Officers to Go on Trial Monday,” Orange Leader,(Orange, TX) November 11, 1951
  • “Orange Police Officers Will Go to Trial,” Beaumont Journal (Beaumont, TX), November 12, 1951
  • “Orange Policemen Claim Innocence,” Dallas Morning News, November 13, 1951
  • “Peace Officers Pay Tribute to Attorneys,” Abilene Reporter-News (Abilene, TX), December 7, 1951
  • “Police Give Watches to Foreman, Two,” Houston Chronicle, December 7, 1951
  • “Police Lawyers to Get Watches,” Beaumont Enterprise (Beaumont, TX), December 2, 1951
  • “Police Will Honor Foreman, 2 Others,” Houston Post, December 7, 1951
  • “Probe of Negro’s Death is Reported Nearing Completion,” Orange Leader (Orange, TX), April 5, 1951
  • “Soldier Says He Saw Cops Beat Negro,” Abilene Reporter (Abilene, TX), November 14, 1951
  • “Soldier Says He Saw Police Beat Prisoner,” Houston Chronicle, November 14, 1951
  • “Soldier Tells of Seeing Negro Prisoner Hit, Kicked,” Corpus Christi Times (Corpus Christi, TX), November 14, 1951
  • Willard Hall, “Education No Hurdle for Alvin Keown,” Port Arthur Daily News (Port Arthur, TX), October 17, 1976
  • Floyd Murray, “Ex-Cop Cites Known Keown Request,” Beaumont Journal (Beaumont, TX), November 14, 1951
  • Floyd Murray, “Orange Police Chief Testifies,” Beaumont Journal (Beaumont, TX), November 16, 1951
  • Floyd Murray, “Orange Policeman’s Trial in Third Day as 5 Give Testimony,” Beaumont Journal (Beaumont, TX), November 15, 1951
  • Floyd Murray, “Prisoner Mistreatment Denied,” Beaumont Journal (Beaumont, TX), November 15, 1951
  • Floyd Murray, “Rumble of Dixie Revolt Rises,” Beaumont Journal (Beaumont, TX), November 13, 1951
  • Joe Parsley, “Around Town,” Orange Leader (Orange, TX), September 11, 1951
  • Joe Parsley, “Around Town and County,” Orange Leader (Orange, TX), April 6, 1951
  • Ralph Ramos, “Former Identification Officials Put on Stand,” Orange Leader (Orange, TX), November 14, 1951
  • Ralph Ramos, “Keown Denies Prisoner is Mistreated by Police,” Orange Leader (Orange, TX), November 16, 1951
  • Ralph Ramos, “Motion for Mistrial is Denied by Judge Sheehy,” Orange Leader (Orange, TX), November 13, 1951
  • Ralph Ramos, “Trial of Orange Officers is Opened,” Orange Leader (Orange, TX), November 12, 1951
  • Ralph Ramos, “Witnesses Out to Discredit Testimony Levi Dorsey Mistreated by Officers,” Orange Leader (Orange, TX), November 15, 1951
  • Bill Van Maurer, “Forced Beating of Brother Told in Officers’ Trial,” Beaumont Enterprise (Beaumont, TX), November 13, 1951
  • Bill Van Maurer, “Negro Solider Saw Prisoner Kicked, Hit in Jail, He Testifies,” Beaumont Enterprise (Beaumont, TX), November 14, 1951
  • Bill Van Maurer, “Negro Unmarked Orange Physician Testifies at Trial,” Beaumont Enterprise (Beaumont, TX), November 15, 1951
  • Bill Van Maurer, “Policemen’s Case Due to Reach Jury Sometime Today,” Beaumont Enterprise (Beaumont, TX), November 16, 1951
  • Bill Van Maurer, “Testimony Ends in Four Orange Officers’ Trial,” Beaumont Enterprise (Beaumont, TX), November 17, 1951