Claude Otis Johnson
Claude Otis Johnson was a 34-year-old Black tenant farmer who lived in Benoit, Mississippi with his wife, Sally Mae, and their five children.
Incident
On the evening of April 25, 1953, Claude Otis Johnson met his wife, Sally Mae, at a local store in Benoit, Mississippi. Johnson, a Black tenant farmer, paid in cash for some fish hooks and candy for his children. John Thomas, white owner of the store and a local justice of the peace, confronted Johnson over an outstanding bill of $37.50.
In a hearing, Thomas testified that Johnson “hit at” him and pushed him against an ice cream freezer before leaving the store. Thomas said he then got his gun and pursued Johnson with the intent of turning him over to the marshal. The Memphis Press-Scimitar reported that Thomas said Johnson, “hiding behind another negro,” “jumped out at” Thomas and “tried to jump” him. Thomas shot Johnson, stating he “had a hold of me and he dragged me down with him. He never did let go.”
Sally Johnson told FBI agents that she had spoken with Thomas earlier in the day about the outstanding bill, and that he was not “apparently angry.” She told him she would pay the bill the following Monday. When Claude Johnson arrived at the store that evening, Thomas approached him and began “cursing” him and demanding the money. Sally Johnson said that Claude Johnson responded “yes, sir,” and Thomas then hit Johnson. Johnson put his arms up “to protect himself” and did not “threaten him, or in any way act abusive to him.” Thomas then retrieved his pistol from under the cash register. When Sally Johnson saw that Thomas had a gun, she pushed her husband out the door and he walked away.
As Thomas walked out of the store looking for Claude Johnson, Sally Johnson stated, she heard Thomas’ wife pleading him “not to do it.” Sally Johnson also “begged” Thomas not to shoot her husband. She said she was standing about 15 feet behind Thomas when “he just started shooting” and she saw Claude Johnson “stagger.” Thomas then grabbed Johnson and fired two or three more shots into his body before he “walked away with the pistol swinging in his hand.”
Sally Johnson told the FBI that a Black man named Otis Dudley was also shot in the arm and that there were several eyewitnesses. She ran to a nearby cafe to get her daughter, Mary Alma Johnson. When they approached, Claude Johnson was dead.
Aftermath
Deputy Sheriff Ray Caffey told FBI agents that he arrived at the scene shortly before 12:30 a.m. and that Johnson’s body had “apparently not been moved.” Caffey found and questioned Dudley, who said that when the shooting started and his arm was “grazed by a bullet,” he “took off” and “did not see what followed.” Thomas “freely admitted having shot the victim” to Caffey, stating “I shot him off of me.” He told Caffey he intended to arrest Johnson and hold him in custody until he could turn him over to the town marshal “on charges of assault committed against his own person.”
Thomas was brought before E.V. Reams, fellow justice of the peace for the 2nd District of Bolivar County, for a “preliminary hearing” three days later in Leland. At the hearing, Thomas testified that he was attempting to arrest Johnson to bring him to the town marshal at the time that he shot him in self-defense. The only other eyewitness to testify was Thomas’ Black employee, Tom Moore, who said, “I didn’t see much; I didn’t want to see much.” Reams and Bolivar County law enforcement claimed they could not find any other eyewitnesses. Reams found that there was insufficient evidence to send Thomas to a grand jury.
Johnson’s funeral was held on April 30 and he was buried in Hazelhurst, Mississippi.
The day before the hearing, reporters from Greenville interviewed several eyewitnesses who told accounts that directly challenged Thomas’. Easter Mae McDaniel, Johnson’s sister-in-law, said she was in the store and saw Thomas run after Johnson. Lucinda Fisher, a 13-year-old, said she saw Thomas “grab” Johnson “by the belt and hit him across the head with the gun.” Fisher continued that Johnson “dropped” and Thomas “held him by the belt and shot at him,” hitting him in the stomach. After Johnson “fell clear down,” Thomas “got down with one knee” on Johnson and “shot him twice more in the chest.”
Newspaper reporting on the case, particularly from Hodding Carter’s Delta Democrat-Times, prompted a preliminary investigation by the Memphis FBI office. The FBI interviewed Sally Johnson, McDaniel, and other eyewitnesses. The FBI also interviewed Moore, who said he “tried not to hear any statements” Thomas made when he returned to the store. His wife, Annie Moore, told the FBI that, upon his return, Thomas told his wife he had “killed him.”
On June 4, Assistant Attorney General Warren Olney III wrote Noel Malone, U.S. Attorney for the North District of Mississippi, that state code gave justices of the peace powers of arrest and that therefore the Department of Justice (DOJ) would be “remiss in our responsibilities” if they did not investigate the case as a civil rights violation.
Following investigation, a federal grand jury for the North District of Mississippi convened in September 1953, returning a no bill. Malone wrote the DOJ Civil Rights Section on Sept. 28 that his office had “considerable concern” about the “results of our efforts to secure indictments in civil rights cases.” He said he was “confident” that “given time, our people will alter their thinking” and civil rights violations “will be eventually eliminated.”
With no indictment at the federal level, the state brought murder charges against Thomas. He was indicted Oct. 20 and tried Oct. 29. Thomas’ attorney argued that he acted in self-defense, on the basis that the altercation originally started in Thomas’ store and Thomas’ claims that Johnson assaulted him first. Thomas told the jury that he told Johnson, “Consider yourself under arrest,” when Thomas approached him in the street. Sally Johnson and other eyewitnesses also testified. Thomas was acquitted on Oct. 30 after the jury deliberated for less than ten minutes. His attorney told the jury that it was “better for a hundred guilty men to go free for lack of evidence” than an “innocent man being convicted.” He continued, “If a man is guilty, he will continue to get into trouble, and the law will take him in.”
Thomas had a history of violence while working in law enforcement. In 1931 he shot and killed a white 19-year-old, Jewell Smith, while working as a police officer. In 1934, he shot and killed a white man, Howard Bates, while he was on duty as a police officer in McComb. Thomas was indicted and tried three times for Bates’ killing and in all instances a mistrial was ordered after the jury failed to agree. In 1937, Thomas was tried and acquitted after he beat a white 16-year-old, Jimmie Isenhood. The Delta Democrat-Times reported that Thomas killed a Black man “while carrying out his duty as a peace officer” in Benoit in 1938. Thomas died in 1973.
Case summaries are compiled using government records and archival primary source material. These include, but are not limited to, investigative records, arrest reports, newspaper articles, court filings, census records, birth and death certificates, transcripts, and press releases. In many cases, the records contain contradictory assertions.
Media Gallery
In addition to the incident files associated with this case, this summary relied on the following:
Genealogical Records
- Death Certificate for Mississippi, United States, State of Mississippi, 1953
- Population Schedule for Copiah County, Mississippi, United States Federal Census, 1940, 1950
- Social Security Administration, Social Security Death Index, Master File, Mississippi, United States, 1953
- World War II Draft Registration Cards, Mississippi, 1941
News Coverage
- “50 Indicted in Oxford,” Clarksdale Press Register (Clarksdale, MS), September 21, 1953
- “Allege JP Shot Negro; He Says ‘No Comment,’” Delta Democrat-Times (Greenville, MS), April 27, 1953
- “‘Blood Stained Whitewash’ is Title of Greenwood Editorial,” McComb Enterprise-Journal (McComb, MS), May 4, 1953
- “Bloodstained Whitewash,” Delta Democrat-Times (Greenville, MS), April 29, 1953
- “Federal Court Action Likely in Delta Case,” McComb Enterprise-Journal (McComb, MS), September 8, 1953
- “Frees Grocer in Slaying of His Customer,” Chicago Defender (Chicago, IL), November 14, 1953
- “Good News from Oxford,” Delta Democrat-Times (Greenville, MS), September 7, 1953
- “Grand Jury Ends Benoit Case Probe,” Delta Democrat-Times (Greenville, MS), September 20, 1953
- “Grand Jury May Get Benoit Slaying Case,” Memphis Press-Scimitar (Memphis, TN), April 30, 1953
- “Grand Jury Returns No Indictments,” Delta Democrat-Times (Greenville, MS), September 22, 1953
- “Grand Jury to Probe Shooting at Benoit,” Delta Democrat-Times (Greenville, MS), September 16, 1953
- “High Court Upholds City in Damage Suit,” McComb Daily Enterprise (McComb, MS), March 21, 1938
- “Identify Victim as Jewell Smith of Hoxie, Arkansas,” Semi-Weekly Journal (McComb, MS), September 12, 1931
- “J. P. Found Innocent of Murder Charge,” Hattiesburg American (Hattiesburg, MS), October 31, 1953
- “John G. Thomas Acquitted by Jury Rosedale After Testifying Negro Resisted Arrest After Store Dispute,” McComb Enterprise-Journal (McComb, MS), November 2, 1953
- “John Thomas is Freed of Charge of Beating Youth,” Yazoo City Herald (Yazoo City, MS), July 9, 1937
- “JP Innocent, Jury Decides,” Clarksdale Press Register (Clarksdale, MS), October 31, 1953
- “JP is Acquitted of Murder Charge,” Alabama Journal (Montgomery, AL), April 29, 1953
- “JP’s Trial Continues in Rosedale; One Juror Stricken, Faints,” Clarksdale Press Register (Clarksdale, MS), October 30, 1953
- “Judge Acquitted of Negro Slaying,” Sun Herald (Biloxi, MS), October 31, 1953
- “Juror Collapses at JP’s Trial,” Memphis Press-Scimitar (Memphis, TN), October 30, 1953
- “Jury Acquits Rosedale Officer,” Greenwood Commonwealth (Greenwood, MS), October 31, 1953
- “Jury Ends Death Probe,” Kingsport Times-News (Kingsport, TN), September 20, 1953
- “Jury Frees JP in 10 Minutes,” Memphis Press-Scimitar (Memphis, TN), October 31, 1953
- “Justice of Peace Acquitted in Fatal Shooting of Negro,” Sun Herald (Biloxi, MS), April 29, 1953
- “Justice of Peace Freed in Shooting,” Vicksburg Post (Vicksburg, MS), October 31, 1953
- “Justice of Peace Go Free for Shooting Miss. Negro,” Black Dispatch (Oklahoma City, OK), November 14, 1953
- “Justice of the Peace Acquitted in Killing,” Commercial Appeal (Memphis, TN), October 31, 1953
- “Mississippi J.P. Freed in Slaying,” Alabama Journal (Montgomery, AL), October 31, 1953
- “Negro Slain Last Saturday Night,” Bolivar Commercial (Cleveland, MS), May 1, 1953
- “Thomas Freed With Hearing at Rosedale,” McComb Enterprise-Journal (McComb, MS), April 29, 1953
- “Thomas Is Freed in Murder Trial,” Clarion-Ledger (Jackson, MS), October 31, 1953
- “U.S. to Probe Old Shooting,” Memphis Press-Scimitar (Memphis, TN), September 8, 1953
- David Brown, “Two Versions of How Man Met Death,” Memphis Press-Scimitar (Memphis, TN), April 29, 1953
- Charles B. Gordon, “Defendant in Heated Pike Trials Two Decades Ago–John Thomas–Principal in Delta Court Hearing,” McComb Enterprise-Journal (McComb, MS), April 28, 1953
- Charles B. Gordon, “Former McComb [?] Who Was Tried 3 Times in Magnolia on Murder Charge, Is Indicted Again,” McComb Enterprise-Journal (McComb, MS), October 22, 1953
- Tom Karsell, “Attorney General Coleman Shoes Interest in Bolivar Killing; Supports DA Decision,” Delta Democrat-Times (Greenville, MS), May 3, 1953
- Tom Karsell, “Federal Court Action Seen in Benoit Killing,” Delta Democrat-Times (Greenville, MS), September 6, 1953
- Tom Karsell, “Fellow JP Exonarates Thomas of Murder Charges: – ‘Justifiable.’” Delta Democrat-Times (Greenville, MS), April 28, 1953
- Paige Masten, “After Learning of Her Ancestor’s Ties to White Supremacy, An NC Woman Takes Action,” Charlotte Observer (Charlotte, NC), September 22, 2024
- Mary Evelyn Smith, “Slain Negro’s Wife Steadfast in Blaming Justice of Peace,” Commercial Appeal (Memphis, TN), October 30, 1953
- Bill Weilenman, “Bolivar Jury Finds Justice Not Guilty,” Delta Democrat-Times (Greenville, MS), November 1, 1953
- Bill Weilenman, “Justice Thomas of Benoit Pleads Not Guilty at Hearing,” Delta Democrat-Times (Greenville, MS), October 28, 1953
- Bill Weilenman, “Trial of Justice in Slaying Case Begins,” Delta Democrat-Times (Greenville, MS), October 29, 1953
- Bill Weilenman, “Witness Says Thomas Was Hit,” Delta Democrat-Times (Greenville, MS), October 30, 1953