Willie Latimer, Eugene Renfroe, and Willie Flagg
Willie Latimer, Eugene Renfroe, and Willie Flagg were residents of Dawson, Georgia. Latimer, 45, was a World War II veteran and father who worked as a plumber. Renfroe, a 65-year-old carpenter and father of nine, was married to Mamie Renfroe. Willie Flagg, 21, lived with his parents, George and Annie Lee Flagg.
Incident
On May 23, 1958, Willie “Tobe” Latimer (sometimes spelled Latimore) hosted some friends at his home for sandwiches, drinks, and dancing. Latimer and several witnesses later told the FBI that he was drinking “moonshine liquor” from a jar or jug. Around 10:30 p.m., Weyman Cherry and J. Shirah Chapman, white Dawson police officers, entered Latimer’s home through the front door. When Latimer saw the police, he grabbed the jug and ran out of his house. Cherry chased him.
In a June 1958 interview with Atlanta Constitution reporter Jack Nelson, Cherry stated that he and Chapman reported to Latimer’s home that evening after receiving a call that Latimer was “creating a disturbance and selling moonshine at his juke joint.” According to Cherry, he “slipped in” to Latimer’s home and chased Latimer outside. When he caught Latimer, Cherry said, Latimer threw the jar to smash it, but it would not break. When Latimer tried again, Cherry grabbed Latimer by the collar and Latimer allegedly reached for Cherry’s gun. Cherry stated he told Latimer to “turn loose” or he would shoot him. Cherry then shot Latimer in the buttocks, explaining, “I didn’t think it would hurt him too bad.”
Latimer told the FBI he fell during the chase. He said he ran toward his brother’s house, crawling halfway under it as Cherry approached. Latimer stated, “he told me if I busted the jug he was going to shoot me.” When he broke the jug, Cherry shot him. According to Latimer, Chapman was not present for the chase or the shooting.
Dr. Walter Martin, who examined Latimer at the Terrell County Hospital later that evening, confirmed to the FBI that Cherry shot Latimer in the buttocks. He removed the bullet the following day.
Around 3 p.m. on May 24, two other white Dawson police officers – Edwin Jones and Robert Hancock– ordered Eugene Renfroe, a 65-year-old Black Dawson resident, into their cruiser. Jones and Hancock later told the FBI they had received a radio call to investigate a disturbance in Renfroe’s neighborhood. When they arrived, Jones stated, they saw Renfroe chasing a girl “with a brickbat in his hand.” According to the officers, they found six shotgun shells, two pocket knives, a cigarette lighter, and two nickels in Renfroe’s pockets when they searched him. Both Jones and Hancock said they handcuffed Renfroe and put him in the police car without any “resistance.”
What Renfroe told the FBI differed. He said he was inside his house breaking up a fight among his children when one of his daughters screamed and ran outside. Renfroe followed her. About 100 yards from his home, Renfroe stated, a police car pulled up. Jones got out of the car and drew his pistol. Hancock then exited the car and grabbed Renfroe as Jones handcuffed him. Renfroe stated that Hancock slapped his face. Renfroe did not know how many times Hancock hit him, but told the FBI “it darkened my eyes.” Jones and Hancock put Renfroe in the car and transported him to the Terrell County jail.
Around 1 a.m. on May 25, 1958, Cherry and Hancock investigated what they told the FBI was a disturbance in another Dawson neighborhood. While patrolling on foot, Cherry shot Black resident Willie Countryman in his backyard, killing him.
Cherry told the FBI that several hours later, around 9 a.m., he was driving with Jones by the baseball field on Main Street when Jones asked, “Did you see that Negro point a gun at us?” According to Cherry, the officers pulled over and got out of the car. Jones identified the individual as Willie “Billy” Flagg, who was unarmed. Cherry and Jones both said neither of them hit Flagg before handcuffing him, putting him in the car, and driving him to jail.
Flagg gave the FBI a different account. He said that the officers pulled up and Jones asked Flagg what he was doing. When Flagg answered, “Nothing,” Jones called him a liar and got out of the car. As Jones approached Flagg to hit him, Flagg stated, he put up his hand in defense. Flagg said Jones then “searched me and then hit me on the head and said get in the car.” Two witnesses told the FBI they saw Jones hit Flagg with his hand several times before taking Cherry’s blackjack and hitting him again at least twice. In his FBI statement, Flagg said that Cherry neither hit him nor said anything to him.
Willie Flagg’s mother, Annie Lee Flagg, saw her son being handcuffed, ran outside, and proceeded to the jail. Annie Flagg said when she arrived and asked why her son was arrested, Jones pushed her and told her to go home. She told the FBI that as she was walking home, Jones and Cherry approached in their car and pushed her inside. She said, “Officer Cherry told me he would knock hell out of me,” but did not hit her. The officers brought her to jail, later telling the FBI she was “creating a disturbance by hollering and shouting near the jail.” Jones denied touching Annie Flagg.
Aftermath
Jones transported Latimer from the hospital to the Terrell County jail the same day he jailed the Flaggs. Latimer told the FBI that when Jones arrived at the hospital, he advised him that he was unable to walk and had not yet been discharged, but Jones transferred him anyway.
Annie Flagg told the FBI that her nephew posted a $36 bond for her and her son the same day of their incarceration and they were released around 5 p.m.
Jones told the FBI he was supposed to appear in court on May 26, but could not attend since he was unable to walk. His brother posted bond for him and he was released the following day.
Renfroe attended court on May 26. He was charged with being “disorderly” and fined $50. While in court, Police Chief Howard Lee testified that police had also confiscated a shotgun from Renfroe’s house. Renfroe told the FBI that the police searched the house and took his gun after he was already in jail.
On May 28, local Masonic lodge leader John Wesley Dobbs forwarded to the FBI a letter from a local Black organization asking for a federal investigation into the recent police violence in Terrell County. The FBI and Department of Justice (DOJ) launched an inquiry and began interviewing witnesses in early June.
A federal grand jury convened in Macon on Aug. 4. Following four days of testimony, the jurors declined to indict any Dawson law enforcement officer for the killings of James Brazier and Countryman, the shooting of Latimer, or the assaults of Renfroe and Flagg. The DOJ closed Renfroe’s file on April 8, 1959 and Latimer and Flagg’s on April 10, 1959.
On Aug. 14, 1966, an unidentified police officer shot Latimer in the back on a street in Dawson. He died at the hospital the next day and was later buried at Dawson’s Sardis Cemetery.
Renfroe died in 1968. Flagg, who left Georgia about two years after his assault, died in 1995. An Army veteran, he was buried with a military headstone in Holly Hill, Florida.
Case summaries are compiled using government records and archival primary source material. These include, but are not limited to, investigative records, arrest reports, newspaper articles, court filings, census records, birth and death certificates, transcripts, and press releases. In many cases, the records contain contradictory assertions.
Media Gallery
In addition to the incident files associated with this case, this summary relied on the following:
Archival Sources
- Donald L. Hollowell Collection; Auburn Avenue Research Library on African American Culture and History; Atlanta, Georgia
- NAACP Papers: Branch File, 1956-1965; Geographical File, 1956-65, Georgia; Georgia State Conference, 1956-1963; Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.
- NAACP Papers: Legal Department, 1956-1965, General Administrative File, Crime: General, June-Dec. 1958; Library of Congress, Washington, D.C
- United States Commission on Civil Rights Records: Justice Program; John F. Kennedy Presidential Library, Boston, Massachusetts
- United States Commission on Civil Rights Records: Legal; John F. Kennedy Presidential Library, Boston, Massachusetts
- World War II Army Enlistment Records: Record Group 64; National Archives at College Park, College Park, Maryland
Genealogical Records
- Certificate of Death, Georgia Health Department, Office of Vital Records, Atlanta, Georgia, 1966
- Indexes of Vital Records for Georgia: Deaths, 1919-1989; Georgia Health Department, Office of Vital Records, Atlanta, Georgia
- Marriage Index for Volusia County, Florida, United States, 1979
- Population Schedule for Terrell County, Georgia, United States Federal Census, 1920, 1930, 1940, 1950
- Social Security Administration, Social Security Applications and Claims, 1936-2007, United States, 1995
- Social Security Administration, Social Security Death Index, Master File, Georgia, United States, 1968
- World War II Draft Registration Cards, Georgia, United States, 1942
News Coverage
- “Can Much Be Expected?” Atlanta Daily World, June 18, 1958
- “Jury Bars Action in Negro Deaths,” The New York Times, August 10, 1958
- “Negroes Refute ‘Reign of Terror,’” The Columbus Ledger (Columbus, GA), June 10, 1958
- “No Dawson Terror, Negro Citizens Say in Answer to Published Report,” The Valdosta Daily Times (Valdosta, GA), June 10, 1958
- Obituary for Willie Flagg, The Daytona Beach News-Journal (Daytona Beach, FL), January 24, 1995
- “Terror in Georgia,” The Washington Post, June 9, 1958
- Jack Nelson, “Dawson Officials Deny Capital Paper ‘Fear’ Story,” The Atlanta Constitution (Atlanta, GA), June 9, 1958