Marvin Goshay
Marvin Goshay was a 24-year-old farm laborer from Dawson, Georgia. He was the son of Jeff and Carrie Goshay and had nine siblings.
Incident
On April 20, 1958, Marvin Goshay was incarcerated at the Terrell County jail in Dawson, Georgia. Goshay, a Black farmer, later told the FBI that at 6:30 that evening, he saw two white Dawson police officers, Weyman Cherry and Randolph McDonald, jail a handcuffed and bloody James Brazier.
Brazier died from his injuries on April 25. During the FBI’s investigation into Brazier’s killing, agents identified Goshay as one of just three witnesses who saw Brazier taken from his cell. Goshay provided a signed statement to the FBI on June 18, telling agents he witnessed Brazier taken from his cell twice: once around 9:30 p.m. for a half-hour medical examination and then again at 10:30 p.m.
Goshay stated that Cherry and McDonald were both present during the second visit, at which time they instructed Brazier to come with them and told him not to bother putting on his shoes. Goshay said that when he saw Brazier the next morning, Brazier was bloody, covered in “whelps,” and unable to speak or walk.
In advance of an Aug. 4 federal grand jury convening, Goshay was subpoenaed to testify about the night of Brazier’s beating. Shortly after receiving the subpoena, Cherry jailed Goshay. During an August 1960 interview with representatives from the Commission on Civil Rights (CRC), Goshay stated that, at the time, Cherry’s only explanation was, “you just need to be in jail.” Goshay was incarcerated for a week – the entire length of the federal grand jury proceedings. The jury did not return any indictments.
James Brazier’s widow, Hattie Bell Brazier, filed a federal lawsuit for damages in April 1960. Two months later, the district judge dismissed the case.
In August, the CRC visited Terrell County to investigate the killings of James Brazier and Willie Countryman, as well as several other instances of police brutality. When they interviewed Goshay, he said it was the first time he told any federal authority about being jailed for the duration of the August 1958 federal grand jury proceedings.
Hattie Bell Brazier’s attorneys appealed the judge’s decision to dismiss the case in September. Both legal teams prepared for trial.
Six months later, on March 14, 1961, police knocked on the door of Ossie and Johnny Williams to alert them that the neighboring Battle and Battle Funeral Home was ablaze. Ossie Williams, Goshay’s cousin, later told the FBI that the “entire front” of the building was engulfed in flames and “smoke was billowing out the windows and front door.” Firefighters responded to the scene at 11:20 p.m.
Johnny Williams told the FBI that after about 10 minutes of dousing the flames with water, the firemen entered the building. Inside, they found a body facedown “on the floor immediately inside the front door.” They carried the body to the ambulance for transport to Terrell County Hospital. The Williamses later learned that the body was Goshay’s. At the hospital, Goshay was pronounced dead on arrival.
Aftermath
In his FBI interview, Coroner C.W. Dupree stated that he received notification of Goshay’s death at 11:45 p.m. and contacted Cherry, by then Dawson chief of police, to request someone from the State Crime Laboratory to perform an autopsy.
Cherry told the FBI that he contacted the laboratory early in the morning of March 15. He also said that he was not on duty the night of Goshay’s death, identifying officers Earl Hufsteler, James Brown, and Raymond Laine as present at the funeral home when the firemen arrived. Federal records do not indicate that the FBI interviewed Hufsteler, Brown, or Laine.
Dr. Larry Howard, assistant director of the State Crime Laboratory, conducted an autopsy on March 15 at Moore’s Funeral Home in Dawson in the presence of Dupree and Sheriff Z.T. Mathews. Howard determined Goshay’s cause of death as “Asphyxia, secondary to carbon monoxide poisoning,” adding that a “small amount of carbon” in Goshay’s lungs suggested “the fire smouldered for sometime before the room burst into flame.”
Howard also noted a “small injury” on Goshay’s collarbone, “melted paint” on his wrists, damaged skin, carbon in his nostrils, and foam in his mouth. He approximated Goshay’s time of death as 10:30 p.m. Blood test results indicated Goshay’s blood alcohol content was .22 and his blood was “90% saturated with carbon monoxide.” The only item on Goshay’s person, according to Howard’s report, was a box of matches in the pocket of his overalls.
Washington Bureau NAACP Director Clarence Mitchell notified the Department of Justice (DOJ) of Goshay’s death on March 16, requesting an investigation. Echoing Mitchell’s language, FBI Investigative Division Assistant Director Alex Rosen identified Goshay as a “principal witness” for Hattie Bell Brazier, adding that Goshay “was reportedly told by law enforcement officers that he would not live to testify in the suit against Cherry.” The FBI began a “limited investigation” into Goshay’s death that day.
Goshay was buried on March 19 at Sardis Cemetery in Dawson.
In a March 31 FBI interview, Dupree stated it was “out of the ordinary” that Goshay was the only individual at the funeral home the night of the fire. The front room, Dupree said, served as a “‘social’ club” for Black residents in the area. He also described Goshay’s death as “irregular,” explaining to agents that Goshay’s clothing had not been burned by the fire. Similarly, funeral home proprietor Charlie Battle told the FBI that as he prepared the body for burial he also noticed that Goshay’s clothing was intact. According to Battle, the front door of the funeral home was never locked and there were people there at all times of the day and night.
After reviewing the autopsy report and results of the FBI investigation, U.S. Attorney for the Middle District of Georgia Frank Evans determined “no foul play was involved” and recommended the case be closed. The DOJ issued a notice to close Goshay’s file on April 18.
An all-white jury found in favor of the defendants in Hattie Bell Brazier’s suit on Feb. 8, 1963.
Case summaries are compiled using government records and archival primary source material. These include, but are not limited to, investigative records, arrest reports, newspaper articles, court filings, census records, birth and death certificates, transcripts, and press releases. In many cases, the records contain contradictory assertions.
Media Gallery
In addition to the incident files associated with this case, this summary relied on the following:
Archival Sources
- Donald L. Hollowell Collection; Auburn Avenue Research Library on African American Culture and History; Atlanta, Georgia
- United States Commission on Civil Rights Records: Justice Program; John F. Kennedy Presidential Library, Boston, Massachusetts
- United States Commission on Civil Rights Records: Legal; John F. Kennedy Presidential Library, Boston, Massachusetts
Genealogical Records
- Death Certificates for Georgia, United States, 1936, 1940, Georgia Department of Public Health
- Population Schedule for Terrell County, Georgia, United States Federal Census 1940, 1950
- Social Security Administration, Social Security Applications and Claims, 1936-2007, Georgia, United States, 2000
- Social Security Administration, Social Security Death Index, Master File, Georgia, United States, 1992, 1994
News Coverage
- “Court Hears Appeal of Georgia $170,000 Death Damage Suit,” Chicago Defender, May 23, 1961
- “Dawson Officers Go On Trial; Widow Charges Fatal Beating,” Atlanta Daily World, February 5, 1963
- “More Hearings in Brutality Issue,” Atlanta Daily World, May 23, 1961
- “Widow Seeks Damages in Police Brutality Death,” The Louisiana Weekly (New Orleans, LA), June 3, 1961